Skip to content

Your Baby is Ugly: 5 Signs it's Time for a Website Makeover

Dustin Brackett
April 11, 2016

Trying to decide which CMS is right for your website?

View CMS Comparison
Read Time:
Don't have time? Download Now as a PDF
It can be a touchy subject. People don't like to hear that their baby is ugly, but the fact is, there's a good chance yours is. We aren't talking about your child, but sometimes it can feel that way when you approach a needed website makeover. 
People spend hours designing, creating, optimizing, and writing content or even spend thousands of dollars to have their website to be professionally designed, only to be outdated within as little as a year. Things are always changing and consumers are getting more and more demanding. They want the best of everything and that also applies to their experience on your website. 
So we're here to tell you, I'm sorry, but your baby is ugly.

No matter how recently you built your website, there is a good chance that it needs a makeover. Here are five signs that it's time for that website makeover:

1. Return Visitors

How many of your website visitors are return visitors? Do you even know? If not, you need to immediately add Google Analytics to your website. It is free to use and can give you very valuable information about the people visiting your site. Seriously, add it now if you haven't already. Everyone loves getting new visitors to their website, but it's important to note the number of return visitors as well. If people aren't returning to your website, there's probably a problem with your site. Maybe your content isn't engaging, maybe your imagery isn't appealing, maybe you're not adding new content as frequently as you should. Whatever the problem, your site needs to be set up to attract new visitors and to get them to return frequently.

2. Lead Conversion

A website is a sales tool. If you aren't utilizing it to capture new leads, then it's essentially failing. Your site needs to be engaging and also provide quality content that a visitor finds valuable enough to provide their information and convert to a lead. Far too many websites don't have any sort of call-to-action, landing page, or thank you page. If you're not collecting leads, it's makeover time.

3. Outdated or Broken Software

A website needs to be constantly monitored. If you're not making sure that your software is always up-to-date, then you are just opening yourself up for malware and a terrible user experience. Not all software lasts forever and building a website and forgetting about it is a terrible idea. Themes get discontinued, plugins die off, and widgets stop working. Take some time to go through your site (on the front and backend) to make sure everything is working as it should and that the software is all updated to the most recent versions. 

4. It's been more than 3 years

Websites just cannot be successful for as long as they used to. The days of 10 year old websites don't (and shouldn't) exist anymore. Like we mentioned, consumers expect more from businesses today and they'll expect even more tomorrow. Your site has to live up to expectations and provide a great user experience. That just isn't possible for a website that is more than three years old. Three years doesn't seem like a lot of time, but so much can change in such a short span. Think about this...

In 2008, Myspace was the top social network in the world. Three years later, Facebook had taken over that position, Myspace had lost over forty million unique visitors per month, lost both co-founders, laid off the vast majority of its staff, and essentially became the butt of all social media jokes. [Huffington Post]

A lot can change in three years and if your site hasn't changed in the last three years, your baby probably has developed a unibrow. ;)

5. Your site visits have fallen off

Every business' goal is to have the visits to their website grow consistently. If your site visits have started to plateau or even *gasp* started to decline consistently, then it's time to take a long hard look at your website and your overall marketing campaign. If people are not showing interest in what your website has to offer or if they're not coming at all then you likely have an ugly baby. It's important to look at all aspects of your website to determine what can be improved from SEO, overall design, user friendliness, content, blog, and even color. 

It's not easy to admit that your baby is ugly, but the sooner you realize that it may be time for that website makeover, the better off you'll be. You always need to be providing value to your visitors and if any of these five signs apply to you, it's time to look objectively at your site. Your online marketing can only be as good as your website. 

Now that you've probably realized that your web baby isn't the prettiest, it's time to start thinking about what that website makeover looks like. We ALWAYS recommend starting with SEO. 


Website Makeover


Latest Blog Posts

The Roles of Inbound Marketing vs. Digital Marketing
Dec 6, 2023

The Roles of Inbound Marketing vs. Digital Marketing

Evan Burns
Inbound Marketing, Digital Marketing

Understanding the nuances between different strategies is crucial for businesses aiming to thrive in the digital age. Two terms frequently discussed in marketing circles are "inbound marketing" and "digital marketing." While they may seem similar,...

Common Problems HubSpot Audits Uncover and Solutions to Fix Them
Dec 4, 2023

Common Problems HubSpot Audits Uncover and Solutions to Fix Them

Jill Schneider
HubSpot Audit

HubSpot. It's like the Swiss Army knife in the world of digital marketing — super handy with a tool for just about everything. Whether it’s wrangling your marketing, streamlining sales, or keeping customer service on point, HubSpot’s got your back....

Best Practices for a Successful HubSpot Data Migration
Dec 1, 2023

Best Practices for a Successful HubSpot Data Migration

Jill Schneider

The role of a comprehensive CRM and marketing solutions is more critical than ever today. HubSpot, standing at the forefront of this arena, offers a dynamic range of tools designed to streamline customer relationship management, marketing...

HIVE Hexagon
HIVE Hexagon
HIVE Hexagon
HIVE Hexagon
HIVE Hexagon
HIVE Hexagon